I really enjoyed reading this as I found it really interesting. I knew that Eliot’s ‘The Journey of the Magi’ was based on the biblical story but I loved the further discoveries that you made with the poem. It is interesting that you link the white horse within the poem to the horse that Jesus rides on within the book of Revelations. That particular moment is Jesus’ second coming, when He will defeat the beast and bring Christians home to Heaven. By simply linking the two, the poem seems to become a lot more fierce, heightening the experience that the persona is voicing.
I love what you shared in your last paragraph, exploring the rebirth of humanity through Christianity. I never really thought of linking that idea to the Wise Man’s questioning of a birth or death, but it seems to make sense and even quite amazing. Your idea of the three Wise Men feeling out of place because of their faith that is separate to the one that is among the rest of their land is really interesting as well. As you said, Judaism was the common religion of that time, and the Bible explores many situations where someone is “different” because they have faith in God–a different god to those who surround them.
Your response reminds me of Matthew 5:13-16, where we are told to be “the salt of the earth” and that we are “the light of the world”. No matter what darkness surrounds us, our faith in God will outshine that darkness and flavour others’ unbelief, hopefully leading them to God. Well done Maggie!